January 8, 2015. Nikki McKibbin died from a brain aneurysm, Studdard wrote on Instagram after Smith's death, family said she had a history of mental illness, 'American Idol' Contestants Who Have Tragically Died Over the Years, 'Love Is Blind' Fans Want Vanessa Lachey Fired After Reunion, Luke Bryan Dishes on 'American Idol' Judges Filling for Coronation-Bound Katy Perry and Lionel Richie, Tyra Banks Ripped by 'America's Next Top Model' Winner, Jesse James' Son Faces Massive Lawsuit Over Alleged Abuse That 'Blindsided' Sandra Bullock, Bam Margera Offered Place to Stay By Former 'Kardashians' Star Amid Alleged Substance Abuse, Arrest, Savannah Chrisley Reveals Surprising Detail About Dating 'Bachelor' Alum Colton Underwood, Chelsea Houska and Cole DeBoer's Careers Just Leveled Up, Dog the Bounty Hunter's Daughter Bonnie Speaks out After Devastating Home Fire. If I could have gone back in time and known what she was going through, I wish we could have spent time trying to help her. The Hollywood Reporter is a part of Penske Media Corporation. We invited them there and then they show up at our house for a cocktail party and Simon goes, What the hell are you doing here? But the thing is, their talent does not warrant, you suck, because these are talented kids.. Cohen auditioned again in Season 8, attempting to sing Like a Prayer by Madonna. Maybe his career didn't flourish the way he expected, but to us, he'll always be a star. I was shaking," Abdul said. And the thing is, that all she could do was get a hold of me through my fan club.. Goodspeed's death reignited the debate over whether the judging on "American Idol" can be too harsh. But, ended up withdrawing from the show out of respect to Saunders after his death. Its a wonderful night for Oscar, whenever you watch! Goodspeeds 2006 audition was not Paulas first encounter with the stalker. When Rickey Smith appeared on Season 2 in 2003, he knocked our socks off as he channeled the Motown era. Paula Goodspeed - EverybodyWiki Bios & Wiki Paula Goodspeed, 30, died last November after overdosing on Prozac and two other drugs, including one prescribed to treat schizophrenia. Regardless of the manner in which these reality stars left us so soon, we'll cherish their memories as we look back at their time on the show with great fondness. Paula Goodspeed, 30, a Season 5 contender whose audition performance of "Proud Mary" was panned and mocked by the judges, appears to have died of a drug overdose, police say. The singer committed suicide in Feb. 2013, her body discovered on her front porch the same place where David Wilson, the father of her young son, had killed himself one month before. Police: Paula Abdul 'Fan' Likely Died From Overdose He didnt have depression. The media outlet reports Abdul wasn't at home. She said: 'She has been a stalker-fan for about 17 years and it wasn't until American Idol that she knew how to get to me. Obsessed Abdul Fan's Autopsy | The Smoking Gun Paula Goodspeed Died: November 11, 2008 Cause of death: Suicide via drug overdose at age 30 in Sherman Oaks, California. Despite some reports of tension between the two women, DioGuardi and Abdul have been friends for years. She went there to sing.". All About Sharrieff Shah, Simon Cowell Was Once Offered His Own Talk Show But He Backed Out: 'Literally Couldn't Do' It, Monterey Park Mass Shooting: Remembering the Victims, Willie Nelson's 8 Children: Everything to Know, Camila Cabello Reveals She Originally Auditioned for 'The Voice' Before Finding Fame on 'X Factor', Simon Cowell Details His First Encounter with Kelly Clarkson on 'American' 'Idol' : 'Stay Away from Me', Pa. Man Accused of Setting Ex's House on Fire 1 Day After Breakup, Killing Her Sister Who Used Wheelchair, 911 Call About Ga.